Sunday, June 26, 2011

“Beyond Conviction” p: 46


Sketch of Yehudah, by Hershel Bonchek

 AyinBase with R' Paltiel p: 46 6/26/11 Sunday 24 Sivan 5771

Page 46 – at end of 3rd line from the end of the page (line starts: hamehavum...)

We concluded discussing the 'ha-arah' element in creation. We showed how all and even the angels with emotion and mind, are still only from this element of 'reflection'.

It an angel experiences a light beyond their level they become completely nullified.
Matisyahu, going for some chassidus....
The angel has mind, and feels like 'it is really there'. mind/comprehension is amazing! It is the furthest thing from being 'natural'. 

Sight is a good metaphor for the kind of comprehension we are talking of. Sight too is 'unnatural'. Sight brings us the truth of what we see, to such an extend that no further substantiation is needed.

Touch is secondary, it is like 'knowing things through myself' as opposed to knowing things as they are unto themselves, through sight. Sight doesn't need substantiation.

Dancing in the steets, Lag Bomer, 5771, 2011, Crown Heights
The same is true in sechel/mind. We learn things and become convinced they are true. This is not imaginary. We don't say, 'I should see it this way, since sechel is telling me to see it this way' - this is not sechel. Sechel is a direct contact/sighting of the topic. This means I have it on an internal level. This is indicative of being a real a existence.  

How do we differentiate between real hasaga/mind and imaginary conception. A simple answer is 'it is not possible to be different'.

This is a miraculous gift and it exists exclusively in a human being.

Naftali giving a gemara shiur
This is what the Rambam says, the beginning and foundation of sechel/mind is to know that there is a First Being. And without that recognition, you find the world on the basis of your experience of it – that's not chochmah/mind. Know the world has a basis before your experience of it! Then you can have chochmah/sechel/mind. Then the world is real. Without this you just have personal experience. 

Angels have knowledge – they are masig elokus – they have comprehension. Thus they are real. You cannot comprehend something real unless you are real.

An angel can speak in the name of Hashem. We cannot. The angel speak in His name and he is also a shaliach/emmisary of G-d. While the angel is totally given over to serve Him, yet at the same time he feels like he is carrying Hashem's message. Yet they become null when there is a greater light than what they can tolerate. They sense they are real, but they lack a final level of reality. 

Man accomplishes what angels cannot.



The human being brings the whole world to a different perspective. He brings reality to the world. It is a folly to explain the world to man from the perspective of world. Man brings significance to world. When planning the moon landing, the Rebbe was asked if there was any objection to moom exploration. He answered, 'there's no problem, but they will be disappointed with what they find.' The reality of world (and the moon) is based on man and torah.


The RAMBAM
The angels are not essential (as are the souls of man), but are only a reflection. They are a reflection of the truth – not the truth itself...




No comments:

Post a Comment